Why have I been so irate? Well, during a conversation with another writer friend this morning, something a third party said was brought up and it was terribly offensive to a) teens b) anyone who's ever been a teen c) people who aren't so far removed from their teen years (like me).
What was this comment, you may ask? Well, it was something to the effect of:
"Kids today (teens) don't care about anything and YA should be dumbed down because of their lack of wanting to read anything of substance."
That was paraphrased, obviously.
As someone who reads (and writes) YA, obviously I had ALL THE FEELINGS when I came across this blasé statement about "today's youth."
One of the main reasons was my age.
Dear, dear interwebs, I'd like to declare a truth to you.
I AM TWENTY TWO YEARS OLD.
I'm about to be 23 (in one week!), and although it's been a while since my high school days, it's not that hard for me to remember the really good times (all of the musicals we did/were able to see on Broadway) and all of the really awkward, somewhat bad times (but hey, they happen to everyone).
You know what I also remember?
How much my classmates cared. About each other, about our school, even about our terrible football team.
But you know what else they cared about?
Politics/Elections (I was a sophomore in high school during the 2004 election, so...yeah)
Hurricane Katrina/relief efforts
Reading every damn book out there.
Learning, understanding the world, understanding ourselves.
Trying to get into a good college/figuring out what to do with our lives.
Giving back to the community.
Some of my most vivid high school memories revolved around the 2004 election. Our teachers engaged us in discussions about what the issues were and what the candidates stood for. For our AP Government class, we were required to attend a political party meeting or volunteer for a campaign. We had to write reports on political broadcasts and shows, and had civil, thoughtful debates in class.
That election is what actually made me care about politics. Going through that class, I decided that I wanted to be informed. I wanted to vote (and I was mad that, at 15, I would have to wait three more years to do so). But it wasn't just me. My point is that all of my classmates were engaged - and still are engaged - in political conversations and are mindful of our civic duties - and it all started in our teen years.
In English class, we poured over Tolstoy, Shakespeare, Morrison, Hurston, Orwell, Huxley and many, many others. We thoughtfully critiqued these works, and, although some of us cared more for certain authors than others, we all cared about what we were reading. We all wanted to understand it. And we all wanted more.
We also were/are dedicated to giving back to others through community service. I loved it so much in high school that, for college, I went to an undergraduate institution with the motto of "Ut Prosim" - which means "That I May Serve." When we weren't working on homework, or rehearsing for musicals/plays/band competitions/practicing to be Women's Basketball State Champs (yeah that happened and it was awesome!), we were doing community service, or working at grocery stores to help support single parent families, or trying so, so, so hard to be perfect - never realizing that "perfect" is this imaginary thing that will never, ever exist.
My point with this rant is that I remember what it's like to be a teen. It can sometimes be confusing and scary to realize "Oh, shit. I'm going to college soon/not going to college and will have to get a job/I have no idea what I'm going to do with my life." It's overwhelming to know that you have your whole life in front of you. And then, when everyone constantly asks what your plan is, and stand there with or without any kind of solid answer, life can be equal parts frustrating and terrifying.
Although I am a few years removed from teen-dom, I'm going to just get out there and say it.
I write YA because I think teens are awesome.
I write YA because I remember what it's like to be a teen.
I write YA because I want to help others (and myself) make sense of this often senseless world.
Something that's bothered me lately is when I hear people say that they've decided to write YA because it's "hot/what will sell/etc." Every time I hear this, I have to fight the urge to shake these people. In my humble opinion, I think you should write what you love, because you love it. Yeah, being published would be awesome. But what's the point in reaching your goals if you do it half-heartedly? If you're not putting your heart and soul into something, I know, I KNOW teens will be smart enough to see right through it.
And the same goes with being "preachy" because you want to teach teens "good morals" or whatever other reason people give for doing something like that.
Instead, I encourage you to write something meaningful. Write something that will help someone see things through another lens, or help someone cope through a difficult time, get them to think through a tough decision, or show them that it's ok to make mistakes. Write about what it means to be human, - to grow, to grieve, to succeed, to fail. Write because people out there (especially teens) LOVE to read.
My only caveat is that you don't write down to anyone. Because, while teens (and all other ages groups) LOVE to read, they LOVE to read things that make them think, that are worthwhile, that are meant for them.
At my high school, we all craved well-constructed escapes from different pressures. Whether someone was wondering if her mom was going to make it through chemotherapy, struggling to maintain their valedictorian status, or understanding why their parents were getting a divorce, we all had something to get through. We all needed someway to cope.
But, most of all, we just wanted to know that someone cared.
I write YA because I care. And if I'm able to make one small difference in someone's life, then I think I'll have done my job right.
So to Hell with writing something because you want to be the next "Hunger Games" or "Twilight." And to Hell with the ridiculous generalization that teens are totally apathetic towards everything and DON'T CARE about what they read. They do care about the world and the things happening in it.
And, as YA writers, we should care that they care.
So, if you write something, write something that will speak to teens. TO them. Not AT them. Write something that you love, and are proud of.
Because chances are if you love it, they will too :)
Wow, what an infuriating thing to say! I'm here because you followed my blog ages ago (Beyond The Hourglass Bridge) to say thankyou and have a decent look around and nominate your blog for an award! I'll have details on mine soon. :)ReplyDelete
Woohoo! I love blog awards :) Hope you enjoyed the look around - and I know, right?!? Sometimes I worry about people...Delete
Thank you for this! I don't write YA, but I have a daughter who is technically going to be a teen in a few months. I spend a lot of time working with teenagers through Girl Scouts, and I know that they are people with as much capacity for intellectual reasoning as any adult. Likely more than some adults.ReplyDelete
I also remember being very involved in community service in high school. I remember reading the same amazing literature for English class, and I remember being given my first taste of adult freedom and responsibility. Teens are constantly told their decisions in high school will shape the rest of their lives. You choose a college or career path, learn how to be an adult, and generally go through more changes in those four years than at almost any other time of life.
Thanks for reminding us all of that.
Aww thank you for your comment! I'm glad you enjoyed my rant :) I totally agree - teens are totally shortchanged when it comes to their intellectual abilities, but they're just as smart/often smarter than "adults."Delete
Thanks for reading!
Love this! I think teens definitely have maturing to do, for the most part (lord knows I did!), but that doesn't mean they aren't smart, intuitive or cognizant. How very condescending of that person to write that. Oh well, his/her loss - they are missing out on some fabulous reading and on a very important age group.ReplyDelete
Truth! I'm still kind of mad about it today haha but yeah, that person really is missing out on a lot of awesome literature/getting to know an awesome group of people!Delete
It seems a shame that people are trying to write YA for all the wrong reasons. I write YA because I love it. I read it. Teenagers make the best readers because they do feel. If you want a reader that will sob when your character dies or become so attached to your mc that they name their gold fish after them or will laugh out loud at your book's jokes, teens. I think it's because they think and learn and grown from stories. When I was a teen, books weren't just something to pass the time. Every book I read taught me and helped shape me.ReplyDelete
I agree with everything you said!!! Books are such powerful things, and teens are such powerful people - I wish everyone understood that.Delete
And I have such a hard time with people who write YA for the wrong reasons. I'll never understand that mentality...
Hear, hear, Alex! This is a great rant. I am about the same age as you and I understand! I actually didn't even intend for my sci-fi story to be YA, but I think it is turning out to be, so I'm letting it! I agree, write what you love and your readers will probably love it too.ReplyDelete
Allison (Geek Banter)
You know, one of the doc students in my grad class on Monday used a general "young people" blanket statement and I almost lost it, 'cause that was the SAME DAY that I was mad about the other person's comments.Delete
I think it's awesome that your story organically grew into YA! It's nice to meet a fellow YA Sci-fi writer :) Good luck with your WIP!!!
Thanks! I am pleased to meet another YA sci-fi writer as well. I am slowly starting to see more books in that genre. I am planning on writing the second draft of my project during NaNoWriMo, actually. Hope I can get it done!Delete
Ohhh good luck! What's your NaNoWriMo name?!? We can be friends hahaDelete
Thanks! You are doing it too then? Would love to be friends :) My NaNo name's allisoneb.Delete
woohoo! adding you now :)Delete